The Lost Island of Mystery Lake

In the sequel to “Fireflies of Summer,” narrator Jeff Vetch and his childhood friend Zeke work during a summer to protect Zeke’s family’s ancestral land on Lost Island from greedy developers intent on building a resort. This effort aligns with the wishes of Zeke’s dying father, underlining the struggles to preserve what is sacred. The story unfolds through a rich, multi-generational saga spanning a century, delving into themes of friendship, familial bonds, and the importance of safeguarding natural beauty. The novel emphasizes the significance of heritage and the fight against exploitation for profit.

Purchase on Amazon

BOOK SUMMARY

This novella is a fictional narrative about a young boy’s summer vacation in 1964, filled with adventures, family activities, and a quest to save a beloved island from being sold.

Arrival and Flight to Eagle River ​

The narrator and his companions await the arrival of Mr. P for their flight to Eagle River, filled with excitement for the summer ahead. The flight experiences turbulence due to stormy weather but ultimately lands safely.

  • The narrator, stepdad Adolph, and friend Bob Harrelson wait for Mr. P at Palwaukee Airport.
  • Mr. P arrives an hour late in a black Cadillac limousine. ​
  • They board a Piper Cub single-engine plane for a flight to Eagle River.
  • The pilot announces stormy weather ahead, causing a diversion. ​
  • The flight experiences turbulence but lands safely in Eagle River under clear skies. ​

Summer Plans and Waterskiing

After arriving at their summer cottage, the narrator looks forward to a fun-filled summer of waterskiing and other activities with his siblings. ​ However, the discovery of a “FOR SALE” sign on Lost Island changes his plans. ​

  • The narrator enjoys a delicious dinner and a restful night at the cottage.
  • He wakes up excited for a day of waterskiing with siblings Alec and Sharon. ​
  • The family enjoys breakfast prepared by Adolph and Bob Harrelson.
  • The narrator sees a “FOR SALE” sign on Lost Island, sparking concern about its future. ​
  • He decides to dedicate his summer to saving the island from potential sale and development.

Discovery of Lost Island’s History

The narrator learns about the history of Lost Island and its connection to his family during breakfast. The island is at risk of being sold due to back taxes, prompting the narrator’s desire to protect it.

  • The family discusses the island’s ownership and its historical significance. ​
  • Lost Island was once home to a small Indian tribe and has been in the Flanagan family since the 1920s. ​
  • The island is being sold due to back taxes owed by Zeke Flanagan Jr., the last heir.
  • The narrator discovers a scrapbook filled with family photographs from the 1920s, showcasing memories on Lost Island. ​
  • The family learns about the island’s auction scheduled for August 15, 1964. ​

Encounter with Zeke on Lost Island

The narrator’s first visit to Lost Island leads to an unexpected encounter with Zeke, a boy who is grieving the loss of his father. ​ Their meeting establishes a connection that hints at a budding friendship.

  • The narrator paddles to Lost Island for a canoe ride.
  • He meets Zeke, who is naked and holding a shotgun, expressing anger and protectiveness over the island.
  • Zeke reveals he is mourning the recent deaths of his father and grandfather.
  • The narrator expresses condolences, and Zeke’s demeanor softens.
  • They agree to meet again, marking the beginning of their friendship amidst the backdrop of loss and change.

The Quest to Save Lost Island ​

The story revolves around a young boy named Jeff who, along with his friend Zeke, embarks on a mission to save Zeke’s family island from being auctioned off to developers. They seek advice from influential figures and undertake various tasks to secure the island’s future.

  • Jeff visits Mr. P, a wealthy industrialist, to discuss concerns about the upcoming sale of Lost Island.
  • Mr. P provides Jeff with a list of tasks to help Zeke retain ownership of the island.
  • Jeff and Zeke work together to gather necessary documents and navigate legal challenges regarding the island’s ownership.

Challenges Faced by Zeke and Jeff

Zeke and Jeff encounter numerous obstacles as they attempt to save the island, including legal issues and the threat of developers. Their determination is tested as they face setbacks and unexpected revelations.

  • Zeke’s family history and the recent deaths of his father and grandfather complicate the situation.
  • They discover that Zeke’s father may have been swindled into selling the island to a shady company. ​
  • The boys face the challenge of proving Zeke’s legal claim to the island amidst family disputes and legal hurdles.

The Court Hearing and Its Outcome

The climax of the story occurs during a court hearing where the validity of the island’s ownership is contested. ​ The judge’s ruling ultimately determines the fate of Lost Island.

  • Judge Letitia Jackson presides over the hearing, which garners significant media attention.
  • RSL LLC presents compromising photographs of Zeke, attempting to undermine his character.
  • The judge rules in favor of Zeke, invalidating the sale to RSL LLC due to lack of proper documentation.

The Auction and Final Resolution

Despite their efforts, Zeke and Jeff face disappointment when the island is auctioned off to a new developer. The story concludes with the boys reflecting on their summer and the loss of the island.

  • The auction starts at $25,000 and ends with a winning bid of $995,000 by PAN LLC.
  • Zeke and Jeff feel crushed by the outcome, realizing their hard work was in vain.
  • They decide to enjoy their remaining time on the island, cherishing their friendship and the memories made.

The Purchase of Lost Island

Zeke discovers that his family’s investments, rather than Mr. P’s money, enabled the purchase of Lost Island. ​ The successful acquisition was made possible through a combination of Zeke’s efforts and a significant insurance policy from his grandfather. ​

  • Zeke and Jeff spent the summer of 1964 on Lost Island.
  • Mr. P reveals that Zeke’s family investments funded the island’s purchase. ​
  • The winning bid at the auction was nearly one million dollars.
  • Zeke proved his legal adoption and dealt with estate issues.
  • The insurance policy from Zeke’s grandfather covered the winning bid. ​

Celebration and Future Plans

After learning about the island’s purchase, Zeke and his friends celebrate with cigars and coffee, discussing future plans for the island. ​ Zeke envisions developing a bait and tackle store along with guest cabins while preserving the island’s natural beauty.

  • Zeke expresses gratitude to Mr. P for the support. ​
  • They celebrate with Cuban cigars and coffee on the island. ​
  • Zeke plans to refurbish the bait and tackle store and build guest cabins.
  • 99% of the island will remain undeveloped and gifted to The Nature Conservancy.

The Legacy of Family Investments

The narrative highlights the importance of family investments and insurance policies in securing financial stability for future generations. Zeke becomes a millionaire at sixteen, ensuring a legacy for his family.

  • Zeke inherits a significant financial legacy from his grandfather.
  • The insurance policy liquidation allowed for the purchase of the island.
  • Zeke’s financial future is secured with managed investments.
  • He is now a millionaire at the age of sixteen.

The Mystery of the Island’s Ownership

Zeke inquires about the history of the island’s ownership and his adoption, revealing intriguing family dynamics. Mr. P and Adolph provide insights into the past, including the card game that determined the island’s fate.

  • Zeke questions why he was adopted and the history of the island.
  • Mr. P explains the adoption decision was based on family circumstances. ​
  • Adolph speculates on the card game that led to the island’s acquisition.
  • The story of the island’s ownership is shrouded in mystery and camaraderie.

Reflections on a Memorable Summer

The narrator reflects on the summer of 1964, emphasizing the friendships and experiences that shaped their lives. ​ The story concludes with an invitation to visit Lost Island, highlighting the warmth of its community.

  • The narrator shares personal reflections on the summer spent on Lost Island.
  • The bond between Zeke and Jeff is strengthened through shared experiences.
  • The story ends with an invitation to visit Lost Island.
  • Zeke Jr. continues the legacy of hospitality on the island.